Student’s Death Revives Safety Questions

Fine art major Nina Fitzpatrick
Fine art major Nina Fitzpatrick

The section of Laguna Canyon Road where an art student from France was fatally injured had long been known to her college, city officials and Caltrans as a crossing in dire need of a traffic signal.

Fine art major Nina Fitzpatrick, 22, died this week after being struck April 3 by an elderly motorist from Minnesota, who told police she failed to see the pedestrian as she drove her car past Laguna College of Art and Design, headed towards the beach.

In aftermath of the fatality, city and school officials this week stepped up pressure on Caltrans to install a signal near the campus, which was authorized last fall, according to a Caltrans spokeswoman.

“This tragedy could have been averted with the installation of a stop light, foot bridge or tunnel to allow students safe access the campus,” said student Sandy Manich, a friend who intended to spend Thursday evening at a vigil alongside the state highway.

On her Facebook page, Fitzpatrick, of Fountainbleau, France, posted photos of herself with a surfboard and light-infused paintings-in-progress of breaking waves. The 22-year-old who lived in Irvine, described sustaining a few bumps while taking photos with a Gopro camera at one of Laguna’s favorite surf breaks, Thalia Street, which she described as her “home away from home away from home.”

The driver who struck Fitzpatrick, an 83-year-old Minnesota woman, was not arrested or cited at the scene. Alcohol does not appear to be a factor in the crash and but preliminary information suggests the driver failed to see the student, Capt. Jason Kravetz said.

Police say the investigation is continuing and once completed will be submitted to the district attorney’s office for consideration of appropriate charges.

Students lined the canyon road on Thursday night in a vigil for student Nina Fitzpatrick. Photos by Mitch Ridder

The college’s president, Jonathan Burke, had raised an alarm about traffic safety last March, saying motorists who travel inbound on Laguna Canyon Road, often ignoring the posted 45 mph speed limit, present an escalating threat to pedestrians near the college’s main campus.

While a pedestrian crosswalk and warning signs have been installed near the main campus and a bus stop, the college’s president and its trustees have argued for improved safety measures that could impact traffic along the heavily used artery.

Even before the recent tragedy, statistics show Burke’s concerns have merit. Of the 45 traffic collisions reported in the 2000 block of Laguna Canyon Road between March 2013 and 2008, 33 took place at 2222 Laguna Canyon Road, the college’s address, according to statistics compiled by Laguna Beach police.

A study of foot traffic and car traffic at the crosswalk and driveway of the main campus on May 2 last year determined that the crosswalk alone justified a more robust traffic signal, known as a high intensity activated crosswalk, Caltrans spokewoman Cindy Azima said.

ridder_nina_fitzpatrick_college_of_art_design_4-10-14_0006While a pedestrian now triggers a flashing light at the crossing, the newer version would set off a red traffic light signaling motorists to halt, according to Steve May, the city’s public works director, who learned last July that Caltrans intended to install the device.

The project, which will cost $75,000, is currently in the design stage, Azima said. “Caltrans recognizes this is a tragic event,” she said. “We’ve told the city we’re going to do everything we can to expedite.”

Some have raised concerns that a traffic light at the crosswalk, while improving pedestrian safety, might make summertime traffic jams worse. An overhead pedestrian crossing, offering safe passage without slowing traffic, is a prohibitively expensive alternative, Burke said last year, as it would require an elevator to meet access requirements for the handicapped.

In the meantime, the college runs a shuttle from 8 a.m. to 10:30 p.m. to ferry students to the college’s myriad facilities that have sprouted in recent years up and down the canyon. College officials implore students to eschew the faster route of using the crosswalk in favor of the safer, if longer route by shuttle.

Safety was also on the mind of Hélène Garrison, the college’s vice president of academics, who said in a statement, “Out of this moment of sadness, let’s all make a special effort to watch out for and take care of one another.”

Hope Railey, the college’s chair of fine arts, recalled Fitzpatrick’s vibrancy. “She provided life to our campus through a constant smile and a genuine passion for life. Our thoughts and prayers are with her family and friends across the world and here at LCAD. Our lives forever will be touched by Nina.”

At the vigil, Burke will announce that part of the  college’s main campus will be renamed Nina’s Park.


Photo: Fine art major Nina Fitzpatrick

Share this:


  1. My sincere condolences go to the Fitzpatrick family over their terrible loss. Despite concern expressed by many individuals writing about roadway-safety we witnessed another preventable pedestrian fatality April 3. Let’s correct the misuse of our roadways before another pedestrian (two per month) is sacrificed to motorist traffic.

    In “Slow Down, Mindful of Life’s Preciousness” Mark Garry wrote this accident was avoidable but inevitable:
    “The pathetic truth of this matter is quite simple; the loss of life at this location was an expected outcome.”

    When is the last time you drove through a school-zone posted 45mph, or through a cross-walk placed across a freeway? Laguna Beach is home to both at LCAD. I blame LB policy makers and their roadway tool Caltrans for misuse of a roadway.

    In November 2011 Pamila Burrus organized Safer Passages to bring attention to dangerous crosswalks. In September 2011 Laguna Streets warned the danger of flashing-strips on PCH in “Put Lipstick on a Pig it’s Still a Pig” .

    “We are here to serve” says Caltran’s David Richardson. Instead of a traffic calming device Caltrans has served us a yellow chicken-strip activated by a panic button. Mr. Richardson claims the statutory posted speedlimit represents 85% of motorists and not easily changed. That measure and attitude is misplaced at LCAD. Instead lets measure the speed of walking students and set motorists speed-limits accordingly.

    Caltrans’ mission is to move vehicles in the most convenient manner possible (FAST), but completely misplaced in a small tourist town like Laguna Beach. Urban design consultant Andre’ Duany warned us: “This kind of place is very fragile and very, very subject to destruction by the 20th and 21st century. Everything that happens out of here ………. to make it sort of work better. But it won’t do that, you will lose it.”

    Caltrans proposes to place a traffic-light at LCAD. Now peer into the future of Laguna Canyon Road, a patch-work of traffic lights from LCAD to Lake Forest confounding LCR like Harbor Boulevard: brief spurts of traffic frenzy between dead-stops at traffic lights.

    Caltrans fails again to exercise their own federal directive by favoring conventional car-centric planning at the peril of pedestrians. Caltrans will try to improve our place at the expense of loosing it. There is a better way. Comply with Caltrans directive (Deputy Directive 64), a mandate passed down by the Federal DOT and implement COMPLETE STREET POLICY on Laguna Canyon Road.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here